Toni Morrison’s Beloved was written in 1987 – a time
much more peaceful than the novel’s setting. Though centered on a culture
that’s destructive, as well as polarized both racially and by gender, there are
strong themes of both love and hate that run thick and through Beloved. Morrison alludes to these
forces constantly throughout the novel, and uses the strong emotions to
highlight different characters, plot lines, and themes.
Although love shines through many
of the roles, the most evident discussion of it lies within Sethe, who has
actually almost become numb to emotion and yearning. Sethe, a warrior in
slavery and through the times themselves, is in a place where she nearly cannot
love freely. She has lost three of her four children, and keeps the last one
left, Denver, close to her heart and in her sight almost constantly. “For a
used-to-be-slave woman to love anything that much was dangerous, especially if
it was her children she had settled on to love,” Paul D. believed (54). Until
she encountered the darling ghost of Beloved, Sethe could not even love her
other children because the memories of them stung too much.
While Denver is with her mother
night and day, she has begun to resent her life at the cold 124 on Bluestone
Road. She breaks and becomes vulnerable when Sethe tries to introduce her and
get her to warm up to Paul D. “I can’t live here. I don’t know where to go or
what to do but I can’t live here. Nobody speaks to use. Nobody comes by,”
Denver vents. The community has become scared of house 124 and of the people
who live inside. Resentment, over time, can lead to hate – the opposite of
love.
Hatred is also shown through the novel
through the theme of slavery. Sethe, Denver, Paul D., and the other men from
Sweet Home are used by Toni Morrison to portray the thousands who were enslaved
during the nineteenth century. The hatred poured upon them by most white people
was enough to scar, and to create a barrier between freedom and love. Freedom,
to Sethe and to Denver, is being able to live with the choices that they have
made and to live as safely as possible. Love, however, is something that only comes
along with immense trust.
The aura and history of House 124
put a dark shadow on its residents, and encouraged the folks of Cincinnati to
feel the same. The darkness has not only begun to control society’s perception
and hate towards Sethe and her daughter, but it has also created a void in the
house. “124 was spiteful. Full of a baby’s venom,” (3) Morrison opens Beloved. Until the ghost of Sethe’s murdered
daughter returns in the novel, the spirits within the family haunt, and further
the distance between them and love.
Beloved’s
characters run for what felt like an eternity, and along the way, learned to
forget love in hopes of forgetting hate. Sethe, Denver, and Paul D. make an
intriguing little family that shows the elements of love during a time overrun by
hate.
Sara, I think this is a really awesome start. Your final paragraph was especially interesting. So interesting in fact, that if I were writing about this topic, I would use that first sentence of your last paragraph a major part of your thesis.
ReplyDeleteAs of right now, it seems a lot of your post is summary, without enough focus to make it into miniclaims. I think, if you come up with a question or a thesis about why the love/hate flow is so important to the story, you may be able to focus all of that into a really great argument.
I think you're onto something profound, here, and wish you the best of luck! Great start!
Thank you, Serena :) My focus will be narrowed when I write my actual paper; I want to stem off into paragraphs specifically about each main character.
DeleteSara, this is a really great post. I agree with Serena about using that sentence as part of your thesis. It has such a strong message and meaning that it would be a great way to start your paper.
ReplyDeleteYou make some interesting points throughout your post and I think that you are on the right track. I know this is just a rough rough draft but additional textual evidence, of course, will make your paper stronger by mentioning certain points throughout the book. Great job!
Shelby, thank you! I definitely agree that that sentence should be used as my thesis! It will be easier to direct my paper and to give it a solid foundation.
DeleteI agree with everyone else that that first sentence of the final paragraph is killer. I definitley think that would make an awesome thesis, but i wonder how much research you could do with that. I'm not great at figuring out what to research, but that one seems like it might be rough to narrow down. The subject is a great theme in the novel as it seems everyone is either moving on from or avoiding love for the sake of sparing pain. you can see this through intercharacter relationships such as the ones between Sethe and Paul D, Beloved and Sethe (this one is especially interesting as the arrival of Beloved destroys any hope of sethe moving on from her past), etc. This could be really interesting to look into and i would suggest focusing on Beloved's role in forgeting/remembering love/hate.
ReplyDeleteSorry, just realized there are a ton of typos in this
Delete